How does this happen?
- Started
- Last post
- 48 Responses
- plash_two0
welcome to crowdsourcing,
you've done good mate..
- iCanHasQBN0
their's was better. there was a concept and story there, something to follow. and it didn't take forever to get the message across.
you were just "rapping" a list of their services... kept hearing words like "shopping cart, domains, hosting". pretty boring. we've all seen this concept before: take a mundane/nerdy/cheesy topic and rap about it in hopes of it being somewhat funny. i honestly couldn't wait for it to end.
- detritus0
I'm sorry to say I kind of phased out after 15 seconds of yours, whilst I watched the other to the end, waiting to see where it went.
Theirs didn't seem so culture, age or gender specific - yours was very much a boys thing for 14-24 year olds. Too aggro, too cool, little heart or humour.
Perhaps that came after the 15 seconds I watched - but I'm a product of the product generation. Gotta catch em fast.
- Perhaps you'd have fared better if you didnt look so much like an agency trying to get an in?detritus
- whereRI0
both were painful
- stoplying0
The nerdy kid one was too fast, hence the subtitles.
Yours was just not really that funny. Sorry. Comedy is a hard genre to do well.
And oh yeah, rap is really annoying.
- honestly0
- ^honestly
- lolanthroponym
- actually. i take that back. go fuck yourself v3.anthroponym
- huh?honestly
- honestly0
i'd say your current state of things is a direct result of resentment.
- eating_tv0
I hate them both. Sorry's.
- ethandmarquis0
Like what georgesIII said, you probably should do a shorter piece. 30" spot?
- ethandmarquis0
Your's is sooo much better. Honestly I don't know why yours didn't beat his. I like the writing. Maybe next time you should do some special animated effects? I don't know but yours is better :)
- monoblanco0
This is a great case study.
It pains me to see how much production time and effort went into yours. I have to agree that theirs, while much rougher around the edges is more effective.
- georgesIII0
I like theirs better,
sorry mate,
your work was good but 90 sec is way past my attention span.- That's it!ethandmarquis
- Wanted to turn it off half way. First place was upbeat, pleasant and catchy.PositiveintenT
- dorf0
- harlequino0
It's because of the messaging. Theirs is about how GoDaddy solves their problem. In 5 seconds I know this guy is out of money, and can't afford Santy Claus. Yours, while more polished, doesn't have that. You're busy talking about domains and registration.
Yours is also in black and white. Their is color. Lots of color. Brand people like that.
Not saying I like theirs (I don't. Not into yours either, no offense). But this is probably why.
- honestly0
yours compared to theirs... theirs being "Do Daddy Go". while their final production polish wasn't as high as yours, they were the stereotypical rappers and sounded more like it than yourself, so do you end up giving it to the ones mocking the rap or the ones actually rapping? lyrically i give it to them. besides, your execution is no where near bob's cheesy nature
- irrelevant0
Mime one was good. I'm talking about the 3rd place winner though.
- honestly0
My Fairytale Finder - lol
boobs: are you looking at my boobs?
pinocchio: no