Logo Crit
- Started
- Last post
- 126 Responses
- codfather0
I like it tho, I think Inu has come up with a goodun...
- lnu0
I read it as point.101 but maybe that's cause I made it :) Also, I'm used to reading mathematical indexes.
codfather: Well, I sort of stole it from soler's work, so I'm not sure I should be getting paid for this.
But a small donation would be welcome... Email me and I'll send you the original file in the correct colors.Glad you liked it!
- BonSeff0
create it yerself ya cheapskate
http://www.grsites.com/logo/
- spendogg0
Ooooooh - I want the neon one.
- ********0
create it yerself ya cheapskate
www.grsites.com/logo
BonSeff
(Jul 19 05, 08:41)That is fucking cool.
- Soler0
Well, can we get a crit goin' here? your homie nessdog dissed it, but noone else has been giving any feedback on the logos that I created.
As far as lnu's stuff, and those other ones people made in 5 minutes-they look like it.
Apparently we have a different eye for design.
So, spendogg, anyone> Anyone have a crit on my logos?
- t_rock0
I agree with skt... don't drag his ass out for public flaying... the logos... not my faves, but that's just my opinion.
- t_rock0
wait... I just read into the post further... $200???? For a meager few sheckles you get what you pay for.
- Soler0
Thx for having my back t-rock but it's cool if that's what he wants to do. I think they're good: regardless of the money, time, and color limitations.
- vespa0
i quite like the 1st one and the 3rd one. but then i liked the original too so maybe i'm just an easy design slaaaaag.
both quite classic and understated. your .101 in the square definately reads better than other peoples' subsequent modifications.
i think everyone this morning went for the 3rd one cos it has a more european design sensibility about it, whereas no 1 looks quite american, but i like that.
- ********0
As far as lnu's stuff, and those other ones people made in 5 minutes-they look like it.
Soler
(Jul 19 05, 10:08)Aye nice one soler - mine was based on one of yours but with a bit more thought behind it. Yep - it took me 10 minutes and was for free. Doesn't say much for your efforts.
- vespa0
Yep - it took me 10 minutes and was for free. Doesn't say much for your efforts.
skt
(Jul 19 05, 10:16)oohoooooo that's harsh skt! your's was based on his tho, he had to think it up, even if it was simple.
- Soler0
sure skt. reduce that down and let me know how those dots look.....
btw, would someone see that and think, Point 101?
- spendogg0
There you are soler. I think it would help if we had the brief, but my first reaction was to the last one - it is clean simple and contemporary. There are many things you can do with that one to get it more to codfathers expectations. I think it would be cool to break it up in colors like the wall color selector in the site - that woould make it more dynamic. and reflect all of the different artists and styles on the site.
Unfortunately codfather cut your process off at the knees, and did not communicate with you first - I would be fuckin pissed..
I am not feeling the first one at all - it is very hard to read.
second one feels to digital for a photography site.
that is my 2Cents.
Hope all is well in lala land.
- lnu0
OK, soler. Here's my critique:
(and keep in mind I haven't read the brief and all I know about the logo is what I've read in this thread and the last one).#1: I like the look of the first one, the 101 part is organic and reminds me of forests and goblins and such. However, I think it's going to need a lot of space around it to work, maybe not ideal for a cramped website or this product. I find it more suitable for a restaurant with an ambient or ecological aproach.
#2: I'm sick of pixel fonts.
#3: I like it, strong and classical. I wanted to emphasize the point so I put it in the middle and then added "point" for balance.
- ********0
oohoooooo that's harsh skt! your's was based on his tho, he had to think it up, even if it was simple.
vespa
(Jul 19 05, 10:17)You just chopped my post in half. It was based on his - thats my point. He comes in shouting about them looking cheap - what does that say about work he wants paid for.
And soler - its says more about 'points' than your version of it. Anyway, it was just an idea for Cod to think about as you clearly hadn't tried very hard.
- lnu0
*leaves thread
- Soler0
sorry to hurt your feelings skt... I was being honest.
Thx for the critique- oh wait, you didn't give one.
- blaw0
not to be a dick, but all of those, including the one i tossed up, are pretty weak.
the exception being where lnu was going, though that needs work, too.
- ********0
sorry to hurt your feelings skt... I was being honest.
Thx for the critique- oh wait, you didn't give one.
Soler
(Jul 19 05, 10:40)Mate. it was 10 minutes worth of photoshop. I'm not going to greet about it. Your the one coming the cunt.
You want a critique?.. lets see.
No 1. Don't like the font. Don't like the spacing of 101. Don't understand what it says about the company or the name.
No 2. I understand the use of a pixel font in reference to 'point'.
but I don't think it works that well with contemporary art and would date (has dated) very quickly.No 3. Funny, I quite liked that one but I thought maybe working on the idea of 'point' a little harder might help. But it looked cheap as I had only spent 10 minutes on it. As did you.
Hows that?
Oh and in general you probably shouldn't start shouting down people offering their ideas and time for free when you have done fuck all that worthwhile yourself.