Sucks or Not?
- Started
- Last post
- 41 Responses
- Tyrone0
oh im going with sucks
- Mal0
sucks for me too.
- save0
shit / wank / sucks /
- unknown0
3 days?!?!
sucks for sure!
- oeuf0
to busy... don't like
- exador10
it has some good points to it...and i can tell she did a lot of work..
but unfortunately its gone in the wrong direction..
the layout is a bit of a mess, it's lost its form and appears kind of scattered..
take a few of the better ellements that you like, and start over..and pay more attention to the over all layout..and dont' get hung up on photoshopy background coloured squares...they're pretty and all..but serve no purpose...
also, the type on that black nav bar looks a bit clunky...not sure if its the font or the size..but its clunky...
rework it..
like it said..there are good things in there..but it needs an overhaul...
- unknown0
sucks, but not a good blow job.
- bostonflash0
now I have until 6pm to come up with another comp...
ahhh!
- dopepope0
AMAZING!
- bomy_dick0
templatemonster ?
- monkeyshine0
wait...who's the art director? or who is in charge of the design direction?
If the answer is you, then you need to be explaining to her what doesn't work and why...not compiling a poll to prove you are right. No?
If you're not in charge, then who is? Sounds like ya'll need an art director.
- exador10
no shit..
i was thinking the same thing..
- bostonflash0
good point. actually this is 3rd round based creative feedback. There's a huge creative brief, site preferences, audience definition. I'm more trying to decide if I'm being too hard on the designer. What if she is right? Besides, this position was for a senior designer, this is great work for a beginner but the senior designer should know when a comp is done or not.
- monkeyshine0
Wow..well, if the designer had good direction and is a senior designer...Id expect more than that...just not very inspired.
- waynepixel0
ya sucks
- bostonflash0
Well, so far nobody said "Not"
I can post my comps when they're done. Not sure I'll rate much better :)
- ER0
i dont think it "sucks" but its not very good.
if everyone says to her its great she is probably not capable of being told the truth. i bet people kiss her ass a lot. just a guess.
- Creon0
Doesn't "suck" technically. i don't like it tho. Too boring. But that's me :P
- willotoons0
ya, I don't think it sucks, it just needs some tightening up. you're already this far - so if she's come up with this and you don't like it - then maybe she wasn't communicated with correctly to begin with.
a lot of these people just throwing out sucks probably like sites that are all flashed out and crazy - this is obviously a corporate site, so it's ok that it's conservative... but it does need some buttoning up. just like some others said - it'd be good if there were some things cleaned up so that it wasn't so busy. the fonts - and the >> on the links can be not linked - stuff like that will help create a cleaner more organized mockup.
hope that helps - and for the rest of you, don't support bashing the designer!
good luck!
- jevad0
it's...something...doesn;t suck - but it sure ain't right!