External hard drives
- Started
- Last post
- 24 Responses
- jiaf0
Up until about last week I would of said western digital, but seeing as how mine has decided to go and die on me I'll have to say no to WD. (It was a 500Gigs WD MyBook.)
- ribit0
everyone seems to have an opinion that contradicts the others...
I've tried a lot of drives (including a lot of LaCies where you don't actually know what's in it), but settled on Western Digital... mainly because they get good reviews for being quiet (important in small home office with the drives always on). Definitely always in enclosure that supports fan and drive spin-down to mimimise noise but allow the drive to stay on and ready to be accessed remotely, or to run backups at night...
- Jaline0
WD. And I use a Mac.
- canuck0
I have a simpleTech, 500gb been working good so far
Not the one I have, but this looks pretty damn cool
- albo0
I'd recommend Seagate because of their 5 Year Warranty.
- cochino0
Western Digital.
I've got two of them, 250GB (USB/FW400/800) and My Book Studio Edition 1TB (USB/FW800/eSATA). No problems here. Thou, the spindown time could be bit longer or spinup faster.
- Stugoo0
got a western digital one. its spot on, totally reliable, recommended by some geeky mates.
never had an issue.
- formed0
Maxtor - got 6 externals, two internals, never a problem. I've used these for years, backup software works fairly well.
Got a Lacie and Western Digital (laptop external drives) that have been good too.
- thumb_screws0
I've found the Lacie's to be pretty reliable.
Steer clear of Iomega found them terrible (drives and their customer service). Bought an Iomega Ultramax 1TB, crashed with in 5 months of purchase and was a shit fight with Iomega to get a replacement. Finally sent a replacement and the replacement fucked out after 2 months. Still in the process of getting them to give us our money back.
Having said that we have an Iomega Ultramax 1TB that was we bought a few years ago and its still running a treat (touch wood). The build Quality on the new one we purchased was shoddy compared to the old one so might have something to do with who Iomega are using to build the drives.
Bought a Seagate Free agent pro to replace the Iomega after reading up on them.
Seagate and Western Digital seem to be the winners.My advice is to read as many reviews on whatever drive you go for.
- enjine0
seagate
- ribit0
If you are using RAID 1 or RAID 5 or even just backing up the same stuff to two drives it doesn't really matter if the drive is unreliable (only one is likely to break at a time, you just replace it), just go for a good deal on a good brand (I think Western Digital or Seagate win)
- ribit0
If you want it as networked storage, I can recommend these:
http://www.synology.comYou have to buy drives separately... 1TB Western Digital SATA 10EACS are good value.
- Arran0
I know of a few people whose Lacies have conked out without warning, so beware. Having said that, i did invest in one myself... just making sure i back up the back up too.
- alexand0
- mine have held up perfectly for 4 years. i have one of the porsche models.
*knock on wood.bulletfactory
- mine have held up perfectly for 4 years. i have one of the porsche models.
- broxybluenose0
LACie
- set0
alexand.
I'd definitely recommend that Freecom 1TB.
I have two Freecom 500GBs and a portable 160gb, they work seemlessly with OS X, they are quiet, stay cool, have a decent ransfer weight and thus far have been 100% reliable