Star Wars: Rogue One

Out of context: Reply #41

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 108 Responses
  • CyBrainX-6

    I just saw it. It may be worse than Phantom Menace. It was forgettable. The robot was very good but I didn’t like (or dislike) anyone else. The story was unambitious and the plot was very thin. They treated this like a Saturday morning cartoon. If you’re going to make a cliffhanger out of the last movie and make the next one a completely different story, it should be great.

    CyBrainX -6Permalink
    UpvoteDownvote
    Flag
    • Also, no heavy discussion of the force at all. It just didn't have that profound feeling all the others have. It's just subpar on so many levels.CyBrainX
    • http://i.memecaptain…prophetone
    • hmmmmmBabySnakes
    • nonsense.fadein11
    • it was purposely not made about the Force - they tried something different and succeeded.fadein11
    • sorry - the plot was a million times better than force awakens which was basically a reboot.fadein11
    • It's a side story. It's not an official episode.monospaced
    • ^ Agreed. They lowered the bar drastically and all the fans seem OK with it. I just don't know why.CyBrainX
    • because The Force Awakens was shit and this is much better.fadein11
    • Can agree at all. The Force Awakens had things and people I'll remember. I wont miss any of these people in Rogue 1.CyBrainX
    • "all fans seem okay with it" = successful SW movie.fadein11
    • I though it was great. If anything, they spoke a bit too much about the force because in that time period the force was though of as superstition.IRNlun6
    • For me it's the best movie since the original trilogy.IRNlun6
    • yep.fadein11
    • "all fans seem okay with it" = successful SW movie.
      That kind of thinking gets you reality shows and top 40 music.      CyBrainX
    • You are insane.ArmandoEstrada
    • Worse than Phantom Menace? With all that jar jar shit and a 3 hour race scene? See above.dopepope
    • No, the new movie wasn't nearly as offensive as all that crap but it at least had a great fight scene, Yoda, Great characters and many memorable scenes.CyBrainX
    • lol - the only person on Planet Earth who thought Phantom Menace had memorable scenes.fadein11
    Show [[ numHiddenNotes ]] more notesAdd Note
    SaveCancel

View thread