Return of the King
Return of the King
Out of context: Reply #73
- Started
- Last post
- 85 Responses
- kpl0
wholly disagree, nick.
the films are authored by jackson, not tolkien. this is his work, it should be judged and critiqued as his, not as just a derivitive of tolkiens.compare and contrast critique is valid, but critique about the movie itself with no consideration of the books is also valid. Same goes with any book->movie adaptation. Once it moves from one medium to another, it changes into its own distinct work.