harsh crit pls

Out of context: Reply #6

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 9 Responses
  • sparker0

    why the pop-up? it serves no functional or aeshetic purpose.

    the site would be exactly the same if you used the browser space provided.

    why do you need an "enter" page? the flash content isn't heavy enough to warn a user about....and since it's flash, it preforms exactly the same on any platform in any browser that supports flash (ie. linux, unix, windows and mac...the major os's).

    and finally...why flash? the site is simple enough that it could be produced in valid xhtml and css and not only be accessible to everyone and everything, but it would be less strain on the server, plugin independent and generate less bandwidth for you - ultimately reducing cost.

    you said be harsh. it makes no sense to produce simple, minimal sites like this in flash. the only loss you suffer is the menu animations...which, really as as user i could care less about.

    :)

    as for the design. clean, simple, informative...works for me...i agree about the fonts, though.

View thread