Layout Crit
Out of context: Reply #63
- Started
- Last post
- 81 Responses
- walkman0
fascinating thread.
I'm a little late in the discussion for any new or more valuable critique. And I didn't see the original that caused such an uproar but I will say that this layout and the josephkosinski.com layout are so simple, that to accuse Jin of plagiarism in this case is a little harsh. Like others have said - why reinvent the wheel. This is a layout that works and certainly wasn't invented by whoever did kosinski's site. But kosinski's does feel and look better for some reason.
But having said that, and putting that issue aside, I don't think that this design is your best solution. Take what you really like from it and rework it. Or dump it and rethink the whole thing. Stick with a simple design that shows your work.
Maybe all you need to do is cut it up differently and reorganize it. I think you can do better. How about NOT using flash.