Design a sexy, glamorous outfit for a night on the town, made from materials bought “at a store that all the famous designers go to.” Sounds simple, but there's a catch: the venue is no fabric store but is actually a popular Manhattan supermarket. Fantasies of silk and cashmere fly out the window, replaced by panicked visions of plastic wrap and aluminum foil. Everything they will use must be purchased here.

Austin wins with Corn Husks & Duck Tape but Wendy coming in 11th withRope Candy, Lifesavers, Tic Tacs might just be criminal.