George Lucas

Out of context: Reply #16

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 23 Responses
  • mg330

    nice idea propa.

    It's just going to be hideous.

    Item 1:
    You're going to have this super futuristic all aerodynamic parts 1,2,3 and then part 4 with the "fastest ship in the galaxy" that looks like a garbage can lid with a bite taken out of it, totally devoid of any aerodynamic component save for a cockpit window.

    Item 2:
    Look at Parts 1 and 2 so far, the bad guys (can't remember what they're technically called)
    are robots that pop out of spacecraft and roll into place for battle.
    Now think about 4,5,6. What are they? They are Storm Troopers, which are humans in the storm trooper uniform.
    How do you go from one year to the future and revert away from something so technological as fighting robots, and divert to fighting humans?
    Doesn't make any sense.

    I think about this ALL THE TIME. Lucas is a total moron with regard to this. He is interested in $$$$$$ and not in providing a decent story. Most die hard Star Wars fans are probably content reading a book about what came before Star Wars: A New Hope.

    God it's sad. Lucas has none of my respect for 1,2,3.

View thread