Artificial Intelligence

Out of context: Reply #184

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 1,362 Responses
  • neverscared0

    Is DALL-E's art borrowed or stolen?
    Creative AIs can't be creative without our art.

    Now, the debate has been turned upon its head, as machines can mass-produce unique pieces of art on their own. Generative Artificial Intelligences (GAIs) are systems which create pieces of work that can equal the old masters in technique, if not in intent. But there is a problem, since these systems are trained on existing material, often using content pulled from the internet, from us. Is it right, then, that the AIs of the future are able to produce something magical on the backs of our labor, potentially without our consent or compensation?

    https://www.engadget.com/dall-e-…

    neverscared 0Permalink
    UpvoteDownvote
    Flag
    • needs to be regulated in the right magnitude .. https://www.bbc.co.u…neverscared
    • We do the same thing, we train on existing material and techniques blatantly or subtly ripping off or being influenced by all those before us._niko
    • Good artists borrow great artists steal
      -Michael Scott      _niko
    • Also dall-e isn’t an artist it’s a tool, go after the dude that inputs “paint a dickbutt in the style of banksy” and even then..._niko
    • u cant rip grand harmonies and relationship of componnents and that is where u edge into beauty except u are a peasant artist... .. that great artist stealneverscared
    • nonsense is utter nonsense..... if u dont evolve everyone gets bored .... great art is is relationship with the norms of the universe not some idiotic rip off.neverscared
    • what should that even mean ? what do u want to steal? take giger´s alien for example one of the most iconic design of the last century.. if u start stealingneverscared
    • u get copyright troubles and u are a loser coz everyone knows u r too puny to do sth. new... or in movies...what u wanna steal? the ryhthmn of a sequence ?neverscared
    • if that probably makes your movie utter crap if it doesn´t fit with the rest of the composition ... and u surely cant rip a whole movies pace and rythmn...neverscared
    • when u read the essential texts fru history of aesthetic theory there is nuffin about stealing it well defined different mindset...https://ww...neverscared
    • https://www.medimops…neverscared
    • i thought its pretty easy to go after the dude since its all traced anyway....neverscared
    • There is no meaning or concept in ai generated art in and of itself the real art is the intent of the artist using ai as a tool_niko
    • And you think Giger didn’t borrow from locecraft and Blake and Dali and kublin and Durer and Bosch etc?_niko
    • AI takes influence of it's pixels from all images it knows on a subject yet it replicates none of the pixels.
      No copyright is infringed.      microkorg
    Show [[ numHiddenNotes ]] more notesAdd Note
    SaveCancel

View thread