Dunkirk

Out of context: Reply #37

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 40 Responses
  • monoboy0

    Watched it last night.

    I found it both gripping and annoying.

    Gripping in the sense that it captures the sense of helplessness perfectly but annoying that it didn't really explore the disastrous actions of the War Office enough for me.

    My grandfather would shudder at the mention of Dunkirk. He wasn't there (I don't think) but had a vehement dislike for British Commanders after his experiences in North Africa and Italy.

    Dunkirk should've been about the politicians and military leaders that hung 400K British and French soldiers out to dry and the civilians that saved them.

    I remember this every-time I buy a poppy.

    __

    And yes, it looked amazing. Apart from the stop-frame plastic model looking Spitfire scene at the end. Really bad.

    • He had special contempt for Field Marshal Montgomery, who stood thousands to attention in a desert in 40° degree heat for an entire day for an inspection.monoboy
    • Didn't show until late afternoon, 100s had collapsed from sun stroke and it gave their position away to a German spotter plan.monoboy
    • They were attacked by dive bombers the next day.monoboy
    • Fübar.monoboy

View thread