Star Wars Episode VIII
Star Wars Episode VIII
Out of context: Reply #74
- Started
- Last post
- 175 Responses
- prophetone3
- he jarjar'ed us again!futurefood
- haha!PonyBoy
- Lucas is a good man. I have no issues with him.since1979
- I just wish someone had the balls to tell him he writes the worst dialogue.monospaced
- THX1138 is a super great movieBennn
- He hides the Boba Fett toy prototypes in his neck pouch.bezoar
- Lucas only wrote A New Hope in the 1st trilogy. Empire had great dialogue.fadein11
- he must be cracking up with how bad this has goneCygnusZero4
- I know that fadein11, nobody said otherwise. Now, who wrote episodes 1-3?monospaced
- you said Lucas wrote bad dialogue? no? he wrote 1 film in the original trilogy.fadein11
- prequels dialogue is actually way better than 7 + 8 though. Force Awakens is an embarrassing mess of bullshit dialogue and fake nostalgiafadein11
- I disagree. I felt the dialog in the prequels was awful. I also have the opinion he's not really a good writer at all, especially with dialogue.monospaced
- lol, as if he's known as a screenwriter... he created concept cinema. he's writes stories, worlds etc. he's never been known as a great screenwriter.fadein11
- Raiders of the Lost Ark? you do know he pretty much created that concept?fadein11
- and everyone has had the balls to tell him he writes bad dialogue, that's why he rarely does write it.fadein11
- love you though mono :)
but come on, force awakens is a crock of shit compared to a good SW movie like Rogue One.fadein11 - all the best with your new arrival if he arrives before we speak again. Best Xmas present ever :) Have a great festive season.fadein11
- lol, you're hilarious ... I didn't say Force was better, or anything else you're saying. I only think he's not that good of a fucking writer.monospaced
- sure he's got great ideas, and I love many of his films, but it's my opinion his dialogue is shit (corny, sure, funny, sometimes). don't act like I can't say itmonospaced
- it's your opinion he's good ... fine, but you need to back offmonospaced
- lol. you said "I just wish someone had the balls to tell him he writes the worst dialogue."fadein11
- he is universally regarded as a bad dialogue writer and director of actors. everyone has said this, for the last 30 years. I must have missed the point.fadein11
- jesus I am not personally attacking you mono. it's just a silly statement.fadein11
- the best SW films had nothing to do with Lucas as screenwriter.fadein11
- dude, if he's regarded as bad, then there's really nothing wrong with what i said, is there? you literally have no reason to arguemonospaced
- I felt like nobody told him that during the process, and to me that's painfully obvious. There's nothing silly about what I wrote. It was just a thought. CHILLmonospaced
- you're getting all worked up over nothingmonospaced
- I'm really not lol, you said you wished someone had told him, but he clearly knows that as he rarely ever wrote a screenplay.fadein11
- Lucas is my hero, leave him alone hahafadein11
- sorry if I came across angry, just a little bit protective :)fadein11
- Lucas isnt the worst when it comes to dialogue but he's no Woody Allensince1979
- look, it was a goddamn joke okay? I didn't assume he had been told ... considering he made a career of shit dialogue ;) MY BADmonospaced
- btw, I'm a fan of his work ... not all of it, but the good stuff for suremonospaced
- okay :)fadein11