Star Wars: Rogue One

Out of context: Reply #57

• Started
• Last post
• 108 Responses

• Bluejam1

  really enjoyed it, def in the top three best Star Wars films.
  added a lot to New Hope and kinda made that a better film.

  SPOILER ALERT

  My only gripe (a plot hole)...

  ... considering we saw a shot of 'golden rod & Artoo' on Yavin 4 as the fleet was about to leave, how the fuck did they get onto the Tantive 5 in time ... they could have appeared earlier in the film rather than 2 second clip towards the end.

  Interesting that a lot of the footage in the trailers wasnt actually in the film ... notably Jyn v tie fighter and rebels leaving bunker v At-ATs ... was that by accident (reshoots) or design?

  Bluejam 1Permalink

  UpvoteDownvote

  Flag

  • I think it was down to the major rewrites/shoots. Was amazed that great Tie shot didn't make the final cut though.fadein11
  • intrigued to know now what the film was before the reshootsBluejam
  • her vs tie was actually never supposed to be in the movie. it was just test footage that was used for the trailers.CygnusZero4
  • odd. test footage for trailers - thats a new one to me.fadein11

  Show [[ numHiddenNotes ]] more notesAdd Note

  SaveCancel

View thread