Zeldman = Bad Designer
Out of context: Reply #36
- Started
- Last post
- 61 Responses
- Dolan0
Interesting discussion, which I think more than anything else highlights the deficiency of the term "designer" when applied to web efforts. I think both sides of the argument here are actually valid, but arguing cross-purposes. I think it's difficult to argue that Jeffrey is one of the key leaders in articulating a best-practices approach to web design, from methodology to philosophy. Every web designer has benefited from his work, and his understanding of the factors that impact web design is unsurpassed. His noteworthy strategies, work on standards, and amazing energy and willingness to share his insights should not go unappreciated. All that said, I'm not sure it elevates his studio to a place where Happy Cog is above any criticism on aesthetics, layout, composition, or style --- and I'd wager he'd agree. In the end, things should still look great, no?