Logo Redesign Critic
Out of context: Reply #54
- Started
- Last post
- 84 Responses
- albums0
k_temp
my only point was the advice he receives here will never culminate to a consensus. There will always be a disagreement on QBN. Some members here need to realize (even myself) that no matter how good our intentions may be, as Janne said, they're not our client.
That McDonald's M is pretty generic, the company did their job by continuing the branding.
this is boring/generic too,
but we all know it through brandingthe thing is though, our subjective opinions really don't matter. It was imperative for me to step in with the McDonalds and other logos to prove the point that success is not measured by a logo that reflects the company.
The success of a logo is directly related to the effort put behind the branding, though there are exceptions. (ie 2012 Olympics) However, this Gotham induced version is not terrible. As members of a forum, our opinions are irrelevant to the the client.
Best advice for the OP is to review the brief and not ask QBN anything about it again. I'm pretty sure the client didn't ask to have their logo experiments floating around one of the most prolific design forums. I'd say that's not good PR for them as now the client is seen to be having difficulty making a decision when they thought they paid a professional to make the right one for them. Instead it was put up for public discussion.
Hardly professional.