Metallica

Out of context: Reply #22

• Started
• Last post
• 55 Responses

• benfal990

  You have to be there when its happening. Pink Floyd in 2009 CAN'T be what is was in 1978 (thats an exemple) applicable to all the old bands that known great success in the past. You cannot recreate the magic and the marks of a specific time in history. Music is a reflect of a specific time and it can't be the same 20 years later. You had to be there. Otherwise, too bad for you.

  benfal99 0Permalink

  UpvoteDownvote

  Flag

  • Well Rick Wright is dead and David Gilmour and Roger Waters are solo so yeah... '09 PF is a little dull :Pismith
  • But even later Floyd (90s Gilmour era) was very good, and so is Gilmour's last solo album.ismith
  • you know what i mean.
    Yeah, its surely good, but its not THE thing it was at their peak.benfal99
  • well, it's totally different– piper at the gates of dawn and the wall were nothing alikeismith
  • I think the two 90s floyd albums were the pinnacle of david gilmour's achievements without roger watersismith

  Show [[ numHiddenNotes ]] more notesAdd Note

  SaveCancel

View thread