portfolio crit

Out of context: Reply #25

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 29 Responses
  • typist0

    alexis, i am sorry if i sound harsh, nothing personal, i expect a better portfolio from a CSM stduent. i am a creative director in an agency. i saw a few hundred of portfolio each year, like 30% is new grad. your site or work is nowhere close to "nice" to me.
    in what sence you guys think she can pull off that heart foundation piece herself? if you really see the whole portfolio, it's stand out and out of the place too, but alexis admitted that only change the text of the heart when i asked.
    for those who said nice work, i think you guys are giving her false hope. it's okie to be a personal site, but it won't get her a decent job in any good studio. to be honest, if you are the employee, will you employ her? now, anyone?

View thread