Carty.
- Started
- Last post
- 53 Responses
- davey_g0
Love the site Carty.
Not a bad list of clients either!
- jonnyquest0
simply saying "overrated" or "jock-rider" is both ridiculous and chilidish. it stands no ground and is not a critique by any means."
lvl_13 is right on the money...
just posting "overrated" is not a valid critique... it just comes across as... spiteful.
"i feel his work is overrated." with elaboration would have been nicer unless cofeesoy's whole intent was to spark discussion.
- robotron3k0
great stuff. it's so nice to see how Carty has gotten better and better over the years...
- Crouwel0
i agree with the alley shoot tho. looks way too staged. but sometimes that is the pun or the intent of the editor. if that is the case then it is well done.
- jevad0
Nice work Carty - as always. Never mind the sourgrapes....
- lvl_130
...you leave such a bad taste. sour grapes!
ehmm, sorry. carry on :)
- TNDAP0
It's all in opinion a bunch of the same dudes in this post who say Carty is just ok, ball juggle people like Build and wanna trade posters and crap like that, mind you I dig build and I am just using him as an example, no hating but I can most definently see where he draws his influences and I most def don't think he's ball juggling material, now paula scher I'd juggle her balls some of you (mostly the ones thta have no clue about design or art history for that matter) may disagree but oh well thats your opinion, I personally think Carty is dope, and given the subjects he shoots mostly urban, I think the shots are framed well, refrained and sort of classic looking, we could go into lighting and all that but I dont want to bore you. My two cents, peace.
- Crouwel0
Nice work Carty - as always. Never mind the sourgrapes....
jevad
(Oct 23 06, 12:07)fuck off!
- Rand0
hi, tndap
- exador10
I've met Carty a few times in toronto ...
the guy not only has talent, he's one of the nicest guys you'll ever meet.
and yeah, along with me and a few other cats, he's an old nter from back in the day...and i think the negativity around here does sort of keep him from posting more...
then again, it's probably also because he's working alot i suppose...and once again...
a good crit or comment is never unappreciated here, especially when it's done respectfully..
however, when it's something like 'overrated' or jockriding..
you're not really giving a critique
lvl_13 is right..
at that point you're just being childish...
- Rand0
it could be worse--in the old days this probably woud have gotten 900 posts
- monkeyshine0
I don't see the point of knocking someone else who is doing their thing. This is a community of peers. You're not going to like everyone's work here but can't you just respect that we're all trying to make our way?
- Mal0
I wish Carty nothing but success he obviously loves what he does and does what he loves and few people can make that claim
- mayo0
well said, monkeyshine.
- Crouwel0
it could be worse--in the old days this probably woud have gotten 900 posts
Rand
(Oct 23 06, 12:21)*nods
- Crouwel0
I don't see the point of knocking someone else who is doing their thing. This is a community of peers. You're not going to like everyone's work here but can't you just respect that we're all trying to make our way?
monkeyshine
(Oct 23 06, 07:40)i am really confused now. was this aimed a TNDAP? or us, the criticizers?
if it was aimed at neue, me etc., i don't see the point?
do i have to compliment the work jsut to be likeable? or for respect?
to me respect is being honest. i hate lying just to be nice all the time. yuk.
- chossy0
crouwells love is like winter I am cold and my toes are numb :'(
- kyl30
silly haters...
- mrdobolina0
I just don't see the point in being a prick about it. not directed to anyone except that guy that was a prick about it.
- Rand0
ICUH8N