Just another shameless rip...
- Started
- Last post
- 26 Responses
- dbloc0
homage?
- kalkal0
IMO, they are different enough (sans editing style/colour treatment/subject, which are also all fairly common themes) to have been put together without either individual person being aware of the other creating their work.
- ukit0
this style really brings you back to the golden days of IDM
- SteveZissou0
People have different definitions of a rip and a homage...
But I'd guess Soderberg had seen Chui's vid and thought "That's cool, just needs my name on it".
- set0
I get what you're saying hombre but it's a bit like saying everything Build has ever done is a rip of Wim Crouwel. Kind of true on some level but also a bit ridiculous.
- PonyBoy0
Rob Chui could say to Daniel Soderberg "hey, you ripped my work..."... but then Michael Bay could chime in and say "hey, you both ripped me..."... and then all the bystanders w/a plethora of taste could feel good about themselves knowing that it was all shit from the start
- orpkoobcam20
I'm getting on my horse and riding out of here.
Giddy up.
- jon_d0
Why didn't you just comment on the vimeo page?
- aldebaran0
what rip?
- Nathan_Adams0
- Lol that's me with the binoculars, the other dude is the old guy calling the cyber police, "i back traced it!!"Hombre_Lobo
- whereRI0
he's even used some of the track in the bg
ive always followed chui's work and this is pretty similar, i mean i wouldnt call the internetz police but anyone in the industry will be reminded of chuis stuff when they watch this...a little too much imo- exactly, too similar. I know your a rob chui fan, i can tell by your vimeo :) thankfully your not ripping him though!Hombre_Lobo
- epill0
i do not see similarities other than music selection.. and sf is not comparable to nyc even though the sf kids will all cry and say it is.
not a rip.. move on lobo.
- orpkoobcam20
It's just a more modern glitchy version of the old NYPD blue titles:
Get off your horse.
- inteliboy0
pretty generic video treatment... not sure who is ripping who on that style these days...
- brandelec0
don't see a rip
looks like any other tony scott opening sequence
- Hombre_Lobo0
Get off my horse?
Move on lobo?You taking the piss? Come the fuck on people, its a blatant rip. Its like same fucking video, you can cut from one to the other and not even notice.
- d_gitale0
not a RIP.
R.I.P thread
- you shut your whore mouth when men are talking.Hombre_Lobo
- lolset
- lolmeffid
- lol, bellendd_gitale
- kingsteven0
Obviously heavily influenced, both pieces are pretty generic and uninspiring (possibly the worst on both portfolios). The Ronin's concept/footage/grading/editing is so superior that there's really no comparison to be made.
Original music by HECQ on both? assuming that's not bullshit on (Daniel Soderberg's part) I'd let it lie. Flaming someone for getting praise for creating original work in a style that someone else does better? ridiculous fan boy territory, no?
- Flaming someone for creating original work? theres nothing original about it you moron!Hombre_Lobo
- set0
So should he move on and then get off his horse? Or allow the horse to move him on and then get off?
- that made sense. derp*set
- Staying on the horse whilst it's moving on would be a far quicker way to get where he's going.Continuity
- ha, thanks for the tips fellas! But I ain't ever getting off this horse! Its a fine stallion.Hombre_Lobo
- calcium0
I don't know guys.
0:00 in the Chui version is exactly the same as 0:00 in the Soderberg version.
I just hope nobody else starts a video in black.