designer vs. designer 2
- Started
- Last post
- 17 Responses
- vague
vs
first guy has slick ass actionscript skills. second guy seems to rely more on heavy imagery and 3D and such.
so who do you prefer, designwise and flashwise.
- mtgentry0
These battles are getting kinda personal, don't both these guys visit this site? That said, everything gridplane touches turns to gold.
- Point50
as much as I am in no position to judge either one of these guys' works, I'm really diggin that gridplane stuff and it may have to do with the depth of the pieces. as I've gotten older I've realized how important functionality and UI are, not just that it's there so people can click around efficiently, but so it becomes an experience and gives a complete feeling to a site.
- I have to agree with mtgentry a bit; and like I said, I can't even hold a candle to the works that even one of them have done.Point5
- ComicSans_Rocks0
designwise & streetwise = GRIDPLANE
- jamble0
They're both superb designers, the portfolio sites are different though. Gridplane is one of my favourite sites anyway so I'd choose that. It's just slick in every respect.
The work on both though is something most people should be envious of.
- Anthony_Turner0
Both these sites are remarkable!
I give full marks to them its hard to decide which wins, based on my opinion though I'd say grid plane is quite similar to my style. (almost uncannily)
- YAYPaul0
Personally i prefer Gridplane's style, but both are great.
- 98328923980
this sort of design is certainly not of my liking, but hey, they are damn good at it. so kudos to them.
- jimzyk0
both are pretty good, both are different.
i remember seeing mister shane's oneill site a while ago and I was well impressed! but the gridplane guy si good too.you cant really compare two designers like this, completely different workstyles.
- roundabout0
designer vs. designer, who started all this crap anyway. There both very good designers full stop, and there work should be represented as that. Hahahaha, I am the best designer, no I am. WTF.
- Killer0
A good designer these days has to have both skills i.e, good at coding and designing. Its a sign of the times!
- Sod that, Just become a coder ,get twice the money.roundabout
- uhhhhh, no you don't.morilla
- cx3news0
I think both designers have amazing work. Most of Shane's work is for 2advanced so it has that "2advanced" look where as Gridplace has worked for a broader range of agencies and I think it shows. Regardless, I would love to have either portfolio.
- mmatthews0
Apples vs. oranges. Rock, paper, scissor shoot.
- helloperson0
Vague, I really hope that it turns out that you are Massimo Vignelli or of some similar caliber. That would quite possibility be the only justification you could ever have for being such whiner.
BTW, you never answered my question back on your post titled "ok, seriously."
- studderine0
i am gonna go with shut up!
- jaylarson0
i've never been a fan of flash scroll bars
- framel730
Its like mascara vs cabellera,.
I like gridplane's style, but Shane Seminole's portfolio and skills are unbelievable.
I have to agree with YAYPaul both are great.