Which Photo...

Out of context: Reply #8

• Started
• Last post
• 23 Responses

• BaskerviIle0

  I looked at them both at larger size (rather than the tumbnails in the thread) and while they both have a 'treated' feel, the second one feel more like an actual photo. The grain and treatment feels too extreme on the top one, it looks filtered.
  Also, the top treatment and adjustment in levels etc really brings out the reflection in the window which they're standing in front of. I find this distracting. I ended up looking more at the stairwell in the reflection and the other people. Whereas in the second image they feel more alone, so I focus more on the two old women.

  There's a pretty obvious vignette on both image, was this in camera or is it added after the fact?

  BaskerviIle 0Permalink

  UpvoteDownvote

  Flag

  • the vignetting looks wrong on the second onegeorgesIII

  Show [[ numHiddenNotes ]] more notesAdd Note

  SaveCancel

View thread