Logo Crit Please
Out of context: Reply #32
- Started
- Last post
- 52 Responses
- JourNYC0
Scotch_Roman
True, a good crit does help from time to time. But would you want to crit every single time only to see the person who is unable to develop for themselves?
This idea of opening design for the masses has created an army of talentless people who think they can design (to my amazement even have an BFA / MFA).
Asking for crit on open forum is rather selective. You get crit from a kid fresh from BFA to someone old like my self. While, I refuse to give detailed deconstruction of the work, when I first see, I just have no comment. Why bother when the work is clearly bad and there is no real room to change. Editing bad work results is less bad work but still a bad work.
If someone tells you that just doesnt work, go back to the drawing board. That always helps.