PSB1 Finalists
Out of context: Reply #257
- Started
- Last post
- 263 Responses
- dskz0
Extended, obnoxious criticism:
#1- Good concept, visually entertaining, good execution for the most part.
#2- (see #1)
#3- good technique, a little out of date, outgheys the original which makes it funnier
#4- technically strong, concept and composition is sound
#5- cool x-ray effect, piitb is the theme of the moment
#6- hilarious although sloppy, but sloppy sometimes is good enough
#7- I love it, its just a great production except for one thing: cats and cat imagery are tired, for me personally. I mean Joystiq did it to death.
#8- Another great production, props on the perspective. But the arm bothers me...was it that ugly in the original piece?
#9- i like the original image alot and this was just flawlessly executed
#10-Probably the best technique of the bunch. The arm bending is very well done and the head looks touched up and crisp. Excellent.
#11-Very funny and relevant.
#12- cool poster, but it aint really PSB material...wheres the source material? in the concept only?