Happy Birthday Marines 1010 Responses

Last post: 3 years, 6 months ago | Thread started: Nov 10, 08, 10 a.m.

RespondNew TopicDisable Images

Out of context: Response #8 [Nov 10, 08, 10 a.m.]

• nilsnihil

  Baker: Politicians constantly fondle a small, clean, paperweight version of this war, as if it provides them with moral clarity. We know that it was the most destructive five year period in history. It was destructive of human lives, and also of shelter, sleep, warmth, gentleness, mercy, political refuge, rational discussion, legal process, civil tradition, and public truth. Millions of people were gassed, shot, starved, and worked to death by a paranoid fanatic. The war's victims felt as if they'd come to the end of civilization.

  But then we also say that because it turned out so badly, it was the one just, necessary war. We acknowledge that it was the worst catastrophe in the history of humanity--and yet it was "the good war." The Greatest Generation fought it, and a generation of people was wiped out.

  If we don't try to understand this one war better--understand it not in the sense of coming up with elaborate mechanistic theories of causation, but understand it in the humbler sense of feeling our way through its enormity--then cartoon versions of what happened will continue to distort debates about the merits of all future wars.

  • The greatest generation failed the USA, Bush & Co. were children of that generation.– robotron3k

  

  You must be logged in to add a note. Login now or register for an account.

  Cancel

  View thread