Science

Out of context: Reply #781

  • Started
  • Last post
  • 1,008 Responses
  • Gnash5

    Netflix Censors Bill Nye Episode to Remove Segment About Biological Basis for Gender

    When uploaded to Netflix, an episode of the educational children's show "Bill Nye the Science Guy" cut out a segment saying that chromosomes determine one's gender.

    • I think zhese peepol need to choose another word other than 'gender'.detritus
    • Hold on - isn't this tantamount to admitting that non binary genders are a choice, not genetics?detritus
    • There are lots of factors that affect gender, both physically and mentally, and chromosomes are only 1 of many. It's not a binary issue by any means.monospaced
    • So if I will it, I can grow boobs? Yaay!
      .
      No.
      detritus
    • Gender should be the descriptor for the base physical layout, regardless of sexuality or identity etc.
      If not, then what other word?
      detritus
    • Ummmm..."Sex". To be fair, Gender isn't specifically biological.Morning_star
    • Mm, I suppose. hadn't thought to be so basic. Well, that gives us a decade before that's challenged too...detritus
    • how old are you detritus? you sound more and more like a Daily Mail reader lately :)fadein11
    • Because I think that denying genetic dictation of sex/gender is retarded? I'm not the one denying freedom of thought here, Netflix is.detritus
    • Either it's natural and genetic, or it's a choice and the Christians are right. I know which side I'm on...detritus
    • I love how disagreement with some ill-founded nonsense therefore makes me a conservative hard-liner. Which is the more blinkered stance?detritus
    • I willed myself to grow a pair of tits once. Didn't like them though so I willed them to shrink, harden and lodge inside fadein's brain. Explains everything.set
    • I'm now conflating sex and sexuality.
      More fool me. Either/or, both are dictated, not chosen, and if they're chosen, then no need to re-write language.
      detritus
    • lol @ set

      Detset - the Brexit doubleact.
      fadein11
    • erm, what? So I express justifiable reservations about the EU, state we're better in it, DON'T vote Brexit .. yet I'm now a pro-Brexit DM reader?detritus
    • You do realise how absolutely retarded the "either you agree with me 110% or you're a nazi" stance is? No wonder middle-everywhere 'hates liberals'.detritus
    • It's like free-thought and expression died.detritus
    • You know my family lives in Europe, that my partner's from Europe, fadein? You know I'm possibly facing having to leave my own country because of Brexit?detritus
    • (...I mean, probably not — i hope — but very possibly.)detritus
    • It hasn't died, really hasn't. But think that if it makes you feel better. And perhaps lighten up a little.fadein11
    • Sorry you misunderstood the difference between gender and sex matefadein11
    • that was resolved before you even blundered in and accused me of being a Daily Mail reader, 'mate'.detritus
    • I'm sorry to hear that Detritus but are you not a UK citizen? I am sure partner will be safe before any trade deal is done - I have friends in similar situationfadein11
    • Didn't see your latest comments before replying by the way.fadein11
    • Ignore me - I am a classic remoaner still bemused at how people thought handing over extra powers to the tories could possibly ever be a good thing.fadein11
    • but of course, I'm wrong here. i am. not you and your presupposition and willful lack of comprehension. me, with my stupid facts.detritus
    • Jesus lol.fadein11
    • My comment didn't come from nowhere by the way - I will flag up as I see in future so you are aware.fadein11
    • With a simple DM :)fadein11
    • Weigh in with bizarre exaggerated opinions, throw some insults in, then tell the recipient to calm down once they respond. Hahaha, classic fadein.set
    • Says the man who calls anyone a simpleton when rational people show your rabbithole theories may be nonsense. Classic Set. Who asked you anyway?fadein11
    • My initial Daily Mail comment was actually a lighthearted comment - but it clearly flew right over the Brexit Brothers heads :)fadein11
    • You really are blissfully ignorant to how fucking retarded you sound aren't youset
    • And there hegoes again. Get back to your fake scientific papers lolfadein11
    • we really are a typtych of twats.detritus
    • ffs, +Rdetritus
    • Is that what you tell yourself? Haha. Love it. Get back to your cognitive dissonance.set
    • a 'twatych', if you will.
      you won't, because we can't but disagree with each other. suffice to say - you're wrong. i'm not though.
      detritus
    • set... I think you'd look great with titsPonyBoy
    • ...on his back.detritus
    • Set is on the blob again throwing his non brainwashed organic Brighton artisan middle class toys out the pram again.fadein11
    • 2 agains goddamit!! Lolfadein11
    • I will be flagging my point and standing up for the good retards of the worldfadein11
    • @det i know you are a decent fella or seem so anyway. My Daily Mail comment really shouldn't have offended you so much thoughfadein11
    • QBN BRM/BRN DRINKS!detritus
    • FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT!detritus
    • BRM?fadein11
    • BRN?fadein11
    • I'm confused again (sorry my small brain acting up)fadein11
    • Birmingham – Brighton, thru LDN.detritus
    • Ah sorry - well I go to Brighton a fair bit funnily enough and often visiting clients in London so it could be arranged. But I dont live in Birminghamfadein11
    • Oh! Sorry, I thought you were based up there. My bad! Well.. I dunno.
      WALES QBN DRINKS!
      detritus
    • not far from Brum - in that vicinity ;)fadein11
    • I'd happily have a beer with you and Set and I am sure it would be really nice - Im not a violent chap. And you both seem like interesting people.fadein11
    • but Set and I have been too horrible to each other too many times I think - the wounds run too deep lol.fadein11
    • WTF is going on here?i_monk
    • ^ in the end it was decided that gender is determined biologicallyGnash
    • it's not decided actually, certainly not by Nye or Netflix's producersmonospaced
    • Oh we should all totally go for a beer, I reckon it'd be great. Honestly. I reckon we'd all get on pretty well in't real worldset
    • Thing is we don't drink beer here in Brighton though, it's full of glyphosate, the carcinogen they spray on wheat. Oh and gluten.set
    • Not to mention they use frog's japseyes to filter it.set
    • Only joking, let's all have a beer.set
    • People that claim choices affect gender are delusional...that is psychotic talk. Anti science denier.Hayoth
    • I wanna have beers with you guys.monospaced
    • I'm up for a drink! I'm t total if that isn't too much a bore!mugwart

View thread